The BBVA award 2013 goes to Rose, Haider, and Urban

January 21, 2014 – Harald H. Rose (Ulm University, SALVE), Maximilian Haider (CEOS GmbH, SALVE) and Knut W. Urban (Forschungszentrum Jülich) received the BBVA Foundation Frontiers of Knowledge Award in Basic Sciences for developing aberration-corrected electron optics.

“I had the solution in five minutes, but it took me twenty years to get to those five minutes.” That is how Harald Rose described the idea behind the aberration-corrected electron microscope. In January 2014, the BBVA Foundation honoured him, Maximilian Haider and Knut Urban (Fig. 1) with its Frontiers of Knowledge Award in Basic Sciences, “for greatly enhancing the resolving power of electron microscopy by developing aberration-corrected electron optics, a breakthrough enabling subatomic precision”[1]. Rose and Haider were members of the SALVE project at the time. Three years earlier, the same three physicists had received the Wolf Prize in Physics (see Wolf Prize 2011).

The award of the Spanish BBVA Foundation came with 400,000 euros. It recognised an instrument that changed materials science: aberration-corrected electron microscopes resolve structures in the picometre range, one picometre being a billionth of a millimetre, and they show not only where atoms sit but how they shift and interact. For nanoscience and materials research, the technique has become indispensable.

A bet against the consensus
Since 1936, Scherzer’s theorem had stated that round electron lenses always suffer from spherical aberration[2]: rays far from the axis are focused more strongly than rays close to it, and every image is blurred. By the late 1980s, most of the field had stopped believing that this limit could be overcome in practice, and in the USA funding for such research had dried up. Haider, Rose and Urban persevered. The jury, which included the Nobel laureate Theodor Hänsch and scientists from Stanford, Oxford, ETH Zürich and Cornell University, stressed exactly this perseverance and tenacity.

At a conference in 1989, attended also by Haider and Urban, Rose presented his theoretical approach to correcting spherical aberration, published the following year[3]. In the early 1990s, the three joined forces. “Our risky project was eventually saved by the Volkswagen Foundation, which also funds research that is not necessarily all that close to practical developments,” Urban recalled. Rose added with a smile: “Also, there was no physical law ruling out our solution to the problem.” With support from the Volkswagen Foundation and the German Research Foundation (DFG), they achieved in 1997 what most of their colleagues had considered impossible: a prototype of an aberration-corrected electron microscope that markedly sharpened the images[4].

Glasses for electron lenses
The theoretical basis was Rose’s design, worked out while he was a professor at the Institute of Applied Physics of the Technical University of Darmstadt. At its heart are magnetic multipole elements that cancel the spherical aberration of the round lenses; later, electrostatic multipoles were superimposed on them to correct the chromatic aberration at the same time[5]. The whole system works somewhat like prescription glasses for short- and long-sighted electron lenses.

Sharper optics alone were not enough, however. Unlike a light microscope, an electron microscope does not show most objects directly but in an “encoded” form, because imaging with electrons follows the laws of quantum physics. Knut Urban and his colleagues at Forschungszentrum Jülich therefore developed computer-based image calculation and interpretation grounded in quantum physics, which turned the corrected images into reliable atomic structures[6],[7]. With this combination, the new instruments detect atomic shifts smaller than a tenth of an atomic radius. “That means we cannot only observe individual atoms, but also their movements and interactions with a precision hitherto unknown,” the developers explained. Even light atoms such as oxygen became directly visible in crystals[6].

From prototype to product
Haider, then head of electron microscopy at the European Molecular Biology Laboratory (EMBL) in Heidelberg, built the device and founded the company CEOS GmbH to produce the correctors. By 2014, more than 500 aberration-corrected microscopes of the new generation were in use at universities and research laboratories worldwide, and over 90 % of their correctors came from CEOS. One of the first of these instruments in commercial use went into operation at Ulm University in 2005, at the Central Electron Microscopy Facility, and Rose held a senior research professorship there, funded by Carl Zeiss, from 2010. Ute Kaiser, head of Electron Microscopy of Materials Science at Ulm, had brought both the instrument and Rose to Ulm. Her SALVE project then took the correction of both spherical and chromatic aberration down to voltages as low as 20 kV[8] and has since grown into the SALVE Microscopy Center.

“We are of course very happy for Harald Rose and his colleagues Haider and Urban,” Kaiser said at the time, “last but not least since this means a huge appreciation for an important field of research, to which the University of Ulm is also very committed.” Rose, then 78, had not expected the award: “Like my colleagues, I was rather surprised to win that award. We are all very happy about it.” His message to research policy still holds: “Science requires dedication, team work and a lot of tenacity. The history of aberration-corrected electron microscopy shows the need for long-term research funding that also allows leeway for failures, as it was also the previous failures that paved the way for the eventual success.”

▸ The laureates

The BBVA Foundation portrayed the laureates in an award video and in interviews with Harald Rose, Maximilian Haider and Knut Urban. The physics behind the award is explained in Origin and Correction of the Spherical Aberration.

Video 1: Award video of the BBVA Foundation (2014)Video 1: Award video of the BBVA Foundation (2014)
Video 2: Interview with Harald RoseVideo 2: Interview with Harald Rose
Video 3: Interview with Maximilian HaiderVideo 3: Interview with Maximilian Haider
Video 4: Interview with Knut UrbanVideo 4: Interview with Knut Urban

The videos play here on the page; clicking one loads the player from YouTube.

Since 2014
In 2020, the three shared the Kavli Prize in Nanoscience with Ondrej L. Krivanek, who had pioneered aberration correction in the scanning transmission electron microscope at Nion, a company that has been part of Bruker since 2024 (see Kavli Prize for EM Pioneers 2020). CEOS correctors remain at the heart of many high-end instruments today. What the jury called a breakthrough in 2014 has become everyday work: imaging single atoms in catalysts, battery materials and two-dimensional crystals, a result of the five minutes that took twenty years.

Download this news article as PDF – for reading on paper, taking notes or filing.

References
  1. BBVA Foundation (2014). Frontiers of Knowledge Award in Basic Sciences, 6th Edition (2013): Maximilian Haider, Harald Rose and Knut Urban. https://www.frontiersofknowledgeawards-fbbva.es/version/edition_2013/

  2. Scherzer, O. (1936). Über einige Fehler von Elektronenlinsen. Z. Physik, 101, 593–603. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01349606

  3. Rose, H. (1990). Outline of a Spherically Corrected Semiaplanatic Medium-Voltage Transmission Electron Microscope. Optik, 85, 19–24.

  4. Haider, M., Uhlemann, S., Schwan, E., Rose, H., Kabius, B., Urban, K. (1998). Electron Microscopy Image Enhanced. Nature, 392, 768–769. https://doi.org/10.1038/33823

  5. Haider, M., Müller, H., Uhlemann, S., Zach, J., Loebau, U., Hoeschen, R. (2008). Prerequisites for a CC/CS-Corrected Ultrahigh-Resolution TEM. Ultramicroscopy, 108, 167–178. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ultramic.2007.07.007

  6. Jia, C. L., Lentzen, M., Urban, K. (2003). Atomic-Resolution Imaging of Oxygen in Perovskite Ceramics. Science, 299, 870–873. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1079121

  7. Urban, K. W. (2008). Studying Atomic Structures by Aberration-Corrected Transmission Electron Microscopy. Science, 321, 506–510. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1152800

  8. Kaiser, U., Biskupek, J., Meyer, J. C., Leschner, J., Lechner, L., Rose, H., Stöger-Pollach, M., Khlobystov, A. N., Hartel, P., Müller, H., Haider, M., Eyhusen, S., Benner, G. (2011). Transmission Electron Microscopy at 20 kV for Imaging and Spectroscopy. Ultramicroscopy, 111, 1239–1246. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ultramic.2011.03.012